The job of examining a phd involves several elements. The examiner may be from inside or outside the university. A sample of 30 experienced examiners dee ned as having examined the equivalent of at least e ve research. The typescript report must contain a clear recommendation in the phraseology below, as to whether. Role and appointment of examiners the university of nottingham. Handbook for external examining of research degrees. This should be discussed, prior to dispatch of the thesis with the sas research team who can provide the up to date guidance. If you deem this thesis to be of exceptional quality, please complete the.
Examiners report on dissertation internal examiner. Generally speaking, the academics who were interviewed hold more nuanced views than either 22 or 27. Examiners of a doctor of medical science thesis by compilation of published papers may select from only 3 recommendations. The author has shown imagination is conceiving a research topic that contributes to current knowledge. Consultation prior to the oral examination the internal examiner is required, prior to the viva voce oral examination, to make contact with the external examiners in order to discuss any issues which may have.
Adequate delimitation and conceptualizing of the field and subject of research. During this discussion, the examiners should agree the key issues to be raised with the research the examiners. The quality of feedback varies between modules but staff. The typescript report must make clear to the candidate the areas in which their thesis is deficient and why, in the examiners view, the thesis is irredeemably flawed. This study gives important additional knowledge for pain perception, as well as for the consequences for quality of life in women with dysmenorrhea.
The thesis does not meet the aqf standard for award of doctor of philosophy or professional doctorate. In australia and new zealand, for example, external. The external examiners report is submitted directly to the doctoral exams team. It sets out the expected standards and best practice for both external examiners and university staff, recognising the diversity of contexts and practices across the university. A copy of the examiners joint report and recommendation form template details on how to claim for fees and expenses for external examiners only details of the current university higher degree regulations a copy of the chairs report template to be sent to the internal examiner when there is no. Research to date on the examination process for postgraduate research theses has focused largely on the deconstruction of examiners reports. An external examiners report on an examination for a doctoral thesis should not normally exceed three pages. Names of external examiners contributing to a collaborative or individual report. Degree of doctor of philosophy examiners report on. The external examiners report is extremely important in this process and will be relied on to assist in evaluating the most outstanding thesis. The evaluation part 2 of the report will be released the candidate once the board of graduto ate studies has approved the examination committees recommendation. Examiners report this thesis contributes to the current knowledge of the effects of pharmacist prescribing and is sufficient for the award of a phd. For most examinations, two examiners are required one internal and one external.
Document analysis of a number of external examiners reports was conducted in. Responding to the examiners comments on my phd thesis blog. The external examiner should utilize the office of the dean of graduate studies as hisher contact with simon fraser university on any issues pertaining to the content and evaluation of the thesis. Traditionally, examiners reports on theses at the doctoral and masters level consist of two components. Part 2 of the report will also be released for the purpose of judging the vicechancellors prize for best doctoral thesis for those candidates who have been nominated. She will receive the pdf version of the examination copy of the thesis and where appropriate share this with the external examiner, subject to the agreement of the supervisors.
External examiner graduate and postdoctoral studies. Thank you very much for sharing your valuable time and expertise with us in this manner. However, the abovementioned study was done on a much larger sample size patients. The candidate succeeded in delimiting the field and subject of research to the learning needs of a specific group of tutors at the. Lynette vroomans phd thesis comments examiner number 1. External examiner report on doctoral dissertation for phd degree name of candidate mgr. Lynette vromans, queensland university of technology. Where the thesis is acceptable but the student has failed the oral defense. In cases where the external examiner recommends that a candidate proceed to oral defence, graduate and postdoctoral studies will normally distribute copies of the report to the graduate program advisor. Indicate your assessment of the thesis by checking one of the boxes below. The external examiners report is valued when considering dissertations for awards. Examiners are required to complete the examiners independent report on a thesis in advance of the examination, and.
Recommendation 5 above is listed as recommendation 3 on the form to accompany examiners report for a compilation of published papers for a doctor of medical sciences thesis. External examiners report graduate school university of. Your role as an arms length examiner for a phd candidate. This is an example of a completed external examiners report and is for guidance only page 1 of 8 external examiner report form template april 2018 external examiner report form for taught programmes 201819 as well as answering the specific yesno questions, external examiners are asked to provide qualitative. A recent experience in being an external examiner for a phd thesis was a most distressful experience which went on for a period of several months covering four distinct phases. Information for examiners of phd and doctoral theses. Examiners report on dissertation lakehead university. Stella lacovides university of the witwatersrand, johannesburg, south africa general notices. At scu, when both phd examiners comment on the outstanding nature of a phd thesis, the candidate may be. I consider this thesis to be of exceptional quality. In either case, the core of the assessment is the examination of the written thesis. Guidelines for examiners thesis assessment report doctor of.
Examiners are requested to i write a thesis assessment report, and ii make their thesis assessment recommendation on form drc6. They accept that being an examiner for a doctoral viva involves the exercise of sometimes fallible judgement, but they see this as unavoidable. External examiner for the thesis of dr stella lacovides. Your contributionis ess ential to the success of our graduate programs. External examiner report template online the following details will continue to be captured via the online reporting process. This article reports on a study of the processes that experienced examiners go through, and the judgements they make before writing their reports. Doctoral thesis external examiner the doctoral external. Accepted subject to revisions please indicate suggested revisions on the attached form. Report of examiners on a thesis examination of thesis for phd candidates and by the external examiner where the examiner pdf a sample thesis report, showing the reader the wonder of the wonder of formatting documents using latex claire connelly melissa oneill, advisor a versions of the sample thesisclinic report 47 a. Procedures could be reports, examiner report asking clearly if the evaluation. External examiner s report name of the thesis candidate. Examiner s report phd thesis example laser summer school. This is an example of a completed external examiners report and is for guidance only page 3 of 8 external examiner report form template april 2018 it would be good to see the inclusion of more creativepresentation skills in assignments. Responding to the examiners comments on my phd thesis.
Guidance for examiners of postgraduate research awards. External examiners report phd thesis proposal introduction creating a thesis proposal after which researching, writing, and submitting the thesis are challenging mandatory aspects of your phd degree. The external examiner s report is submitted directly to the doctoral exams team at graduate and postdoctoral studies. Degree of doctor of philosophy examiners report on revised. Masters thesis examiner for a masters thesis, the examiner must be a scholar of established reputation and competence in the field of the thesis research. Please note, an arms length examiner must atted the defen e eitns her in person or. The doctor of philosophy phd is a research degree which comprises a thesis to the value of 360 credits. Report of examiners on a thesis examination of thesis for phd candidates and by the external examiner where the examiner pdf a sample thesis report. The external examiner should normally communicate and coordinate logistical. External examiners report graduate school university. The oral examination is frequently ceremonial or celebratory jackson and tinkler 564 c. The examination at the university of canterbury has two stages. The standards to be attained for each degree are formulated in general regulation 23 for research degrees, which requires that for the degree of phd, dpt, edd, engd, md or chm, the thesis makes a distinct contribution to.
Examiners independent report on a postgraduate research thesis, and there will be an opportunity for discussion between the examiners at a preliminary meeting directly before the viva voce. Masters thesis two examiners either one internal examiner and one external examiner, or two internal examiners doctoral thesis three examiners at least one external examiner the oral examination panel will be a subset of the thesis examination panel, two of whom must be present physically or via. In the case of a doctoral thesis involving creative works, the thesis comprises the creative work which will normally. Examiners report continued d grounds for recommendation please state the grounds on which you base your recommendation relative to the statements about the content and presentation of the thesis in a above. External examiners play an important role in ensuring that the thesis and the knowledge displayed by the candidate are comparable to those of candidates being examined for the same degree at another university and it is therefore essential that staff appointed. External examiners report graduate school university of british. Stella lacovides university of the witwatersrand, johannesburg,south africa general notices. Radka kozakova title of thesis the early medieval landscape and transformation during the high medieval colonization dissertation supervisor mgr. Australia, a thesis examination typically consists of two or three examiners reading the thesis and writing a report recommending a result, while in other countries, such as new zealand, a viva or oral examination is a common addition. Qualities and characteristics in the written reports of. Guidance for internal and external examiners of candidates. Units may nominate a member from within the unit who is not in conflict of interest see conflict of interest checklist. In cases where the external examiner recommends that a candidate proceed to oral defence, graduate and postdoctoral studies will normally distribute copies of the report to the graduate program advisor and all members of the examination committee one week prior. External examiners doc the university of edinburgh the university of edinburgh.
External examiners play an important role in ensuring that the thesis and the knowledge displayed by the candidate are comparable to those of candidates being examined for the same degree at another university and it is therefore essential that staff appointed should have the necessary expertise to fulfil this role. The candidate should not be awarded the degree of phd or professional doctorate, but should be allowed to revise the thesis and resubmit the thesis for examination as a masters by thesis. Registry ii the main contributions to the field that have been made by the thesis. Thesis examiners graduate and postdoctoral studies. Instructions for preparing the external examiners report.
Freedom of information acts the texts of the external and internal examiners reports are initially available only to the dean of graduate. External examiner report form for taught programmes 201819 as well as answering the specific yesno questions, external examiners are asked to provide qualitative comments in each section, to assist the university, school and the programme team in managing standards and quality effectively. The external examiner is asked to assess whether the dissertation meets the. Report if more space is required, use reverse side. My top 25 tips for phd students published on august 29, 2015 august 29, 2015 1,361 likes 111 comments. Examiners report on masters thesis university of auckland. External examiners report phd thesis writing focus of program phasea phaseb final examination, the. Jan 27, 2016 friends, through this blog i would love to share the story of my journey in unfolding my life mystery. Examiners report for higher degrees by research once completed. Internal examiners are sometimes responsible for the organisation of the viva and arrangements for the external examiners travel, accommodation and entertainment. In addition she should act as the facilitator of the administrative arrangements for the examination of the thesis and of the viva voce examination. This study gives important additional knowledge for pain perception, as well as for the consequences for. Friends, through this blog i would love to share the story of my journey in unfolding my life mystery.
An invitation to serve as an external examiner represents recognition of expertise and. Following receipt of all three thesis assessment reports, the examination convenor, will arrange a vivaor oral with the candidate and two examiners, normally the internal and one external examiner. Institution charles university of prague, faculty of science, department of botany. In some countries, such as australia, a thesis examination typically consists of two or three examiners. Assessing the quality of the thesis is the most important of the examiners functions. At the university of british columbia, expert assessment by an external examiner is an essential and valued component of our final doctoral examination process. In cases where examiners are not unanimous in their recommendations, a. Accepted subject to revisions please indicate suggested revisions.
The handbook provides guidance and practical advice on external examining of research degrees. The external examiners report is submitted directly to the doctoral exams team at graduate and postdoctoral studies. External examiner report on doctoral dissertation for phd degree. Phd and the mphil is one of depth and sophistication and hence for example external examiners report university of st andrews phd2 external examiners report form. Lynette vroomans phd thesis comments examiner number 1 keywords. External examiners report name of the thesis candidate. What i have achieved so far and in the future is driven by my love, which is reflected in what i have done to the people, the society and the environment around me. Adequate delimitation and conceptualizing of the field. Pdf the voice of the external examiner in masters dissertations. University of dublin trinity college dublin guidelines for.
630 478 1150 376 1502 1394 315 1093 655 1518 139 598 801 837 982 1581 155 735 66 1287 1051 1334 961 116 411 1108 1088 1172 809 231 302 504 90 1449 618 595 374 224 493 538 1276 766 863